11 Differences Between Traditional Publishing and Self-Publishing
From literary agents, contracts, production timelines, and marketing, there are a lot of differences between having a book traditionally published and choosing to self-publish.
Publishing a book is an exciting journey for any author. The path to getting a book published, however, varies depending on whether you choose traditional publishing or self-publishing for your book.
So, let’s explore the main differences between the two approaches.
1. Literary Agents and Publishers
One of the key distinctions between traditional publishing and self-publishing is the involvement of literary agents and publishers. In traditional publishing, authors need to secure a literary agent to represent their work and negotiate publishing deals on the author’s behalf.
Literary agents have established connections in the publishing industry, which helps authors navigate the complex world of publishing. On the other hand, self-publishing allows authors to bypass the need for a literary agent and work directly with platforms or distributors to publish their books.
2. Publishing Contracts
When it comes to publishing contracts, traditional publishing and self-publishing follow different models. In traditional publishing, authors sign contracts with publishing houses that outline the terms and conditions of publishing their work. These contracts often cover royalties, rights, and marketing efforts.
In contrast, self-publishing authors retain full control over their work and have more flexibility when it comes to the terms of publishing contracts.
3. Costs for the Author
Costs can be a significant factor when deciding between traditional publishing and self-publishing. In traditional publishing, the publisher covers the majority of the costs associated with editing, cover design, printing, and distribution. However, authors often receive a smaller percentage of the book's profits in return.
Self-published authors, however, are responsible for covering 100% of the editing, production, printing, distribution, and marketing costs. While this may require an initial investment, self-publishing authors can potentially earn a higher percentage of the book's profits in the long run.
4. Timeline to a Published Book
When it comes to the timeline for getting a book published, it varies greatly between traditional publishing and self-publishing.
In traditional publishing, if a manuscript is completed and there is already a contract on the table, it can take anywhere from nine months to two years for a book to be published. This is due to the size of the press and whether a publishing schedule for the upcoming year has already been planned or not. The traditional publishing schedule must also account for the time needed for multiple rounds of editing and fact-checking, designing the interior of the book, designing the book cover, as well as printing and shipping times. Advanced reader copies (ARCs) also need to be printed and shipped or the files need to be converted into eBook files and distributed to book reviewers and author interviewees, so they have enough time with the book to prepare their work.
Self-publishing, on the other hand, offers an expedited process. With self-publishing, authors have the freedom to control every aspect of the publishing journey. They can choose to work with freelance editors, designers, and marketers, or they can utilize self-publishing platforms that provide these services in one place. This allows authors to bypass the lengthy submission and review process of traditional publishing and get their books out into the world without delays.
5. Book Editing
Both traditional publishing and self-publishing require professional editing to ensure the quality of the final product. In traditional publishing, the publisher typically provides professional editors who work closely with the author to refine the manuscript. This editing process helps polish the book and ensure it meets industry standards. In self-publishing, authors must find an editor and pay for the editorial services to improve their manuscripts.
6. Book Production
The production process can also differ between traditional publishing and self-publishing. In traditional publishing, publishers handle the tasks of formatting, typesetting, and designing the book's interior. They also take care of cover design and printing.
Self-publishing authors, on the other hand, need to handle these aspects themselves, hire professionals to assist them or use self-publishing platforms (like Xulon Press) that provide these services in one place.
7. Book Cover Design
In traditional publishing, publishers typically have in-house design teams or work with professional designers to create captivating book covers that align with market trends.
Self-publishing authors have the freedom to choose their own cover designers or use online design tools to create eye-catching covers. It’s essential, however, for self-publishing authors to invest in professional cover design to ensure their books stand out in a crowded market.
8. Pre-Marketing
Pre-marketing plays a crucial role in generating buzz and anticipation for a book. Traditional publishing houses often have established marketing departments and distribution networks to promote their upcoming releases. They invest in pre-marketing efforts such as cover reveals, author interviews, and ARCs to generate interest.
In self-publishing, authors are responsible for their own pre-marketing activities. This can include building and growing a social media presence, reaching out to influencers or book bloggers, and organizing virtual or physical launch events.
9. Book Pre-Sales
Pre-sales can be an effective strategy to generate early sales and build momentum for a book's release. Traditional publishing often includes presale periods where readers can pre-order the book before its official launch. Pre-sales help gauge the level of interest in the book and can contribute to bestseller lists.
In self-publishing, authors can also leverage pre-sales by setting up pre-order campaigns on various online platforms. This allows them to build anticipation and secure early sales. In self-publishing, however, the author is still responsible for setting up the pre-order campaign.
10. Best Seller Lists
Landing a spot on a bestseller list is a significant achievement for any author. In traditional publishing, bestseller lists are often dominated by books from established publishing houses. These lists are determined by factors like sales volume, distribution, and critical acclaim. In self-publishing, authors have a bit more of an uphill climb to land on bestseller lists, but it’s not impossible.
Self-published authors will need to leverage highly targeted marketing and PR strategies, build a loyal readership, and generate sales and positive reviews.
11. Book Reviews
Reviews can greatly impact a book's success and reputation. In traditional publishing, publishers typically have established relationships in place with professional reviewers and media outlets who provide early reviews and book endorsements.
Self-publishing authors can also seek reviews from book bloggers and influencers or engage in review exchange communities. Positive reviews help all authors, traditionally published or self-published, build credibility and attract new readers to their books.
Upcoming article: Preptober: Planning Checklist for NaNoWriMo
Have a productive writing week 🖊️
If you’re finding this newsletter valuable, share it with a friend or on social media!
Such a thorough explanation in a brief format. Thank you for making sense out of this topic