📬 Open Now If You Want to Know How to Avoid These 9 Common Mistakes First-Time Writers Make
Today's post is available for all subscribers! Happy reading 👓
Writing a book is an exciting journey, but first-time authors often encounter obstacles that may slow them down or derail their progress. From battling perfectionism to neglecting book marketing, these common mistakes can make the publishing route more difficult than it needs to be.
The good news? With the right strategies, you can avoid these common pitfalls and set yourself up for success.
In today’s article, I’m sharing nine common mistakes new authors make and providing practical solutions to help you avoid them. Whether you're starting your first draft or preparing to publish, these suggestions can help you navigate the writing and publishing process with confidence.
Mistake #1: Inconsistent Writing Habits
One of the biggest challenges first-time writers face is maintaining writing routine consistency. Many writers start with boatloads of enthusiasm but eventually struggle to keep up momentum when life gets busy or inspiration fades. If you write only when motivation strikes, you may experience long gaps between writing sessions, which makes it harder to finish a book.
To course correct this mistake, establish a dedicated writing schedule that fits your lifestyle. Your writing routine doesn’t have to be daily, but consistency is key. Whether you write for 30 minutes every morning, dedicate your lunch break to your book, or set aside specific days of the week to write, having a routine will help you make steady progress. Creating rituals, such as writing in the same spot, listening to a specific playlist, or starting with a warm-up exercise, can also help trigger your productive mindset.
Finally, accountability can make a huge difference. Join a writing group, set personal deadlines for yourself, or use a tracking tool to monitor your progress. Writing is a skill that improves with practice, so the more consistently you show up the stronger your work can become.
Mistake #2: Overloading the First Draft with Perfectionism
Many new writers are scared of writing badly. They tear apart every sentence. They rewrite and edit everything, so they never truly move forward. While striving for excellence is commendable, perfectionism during the first draft is paralyzing. Instead of focusing on getting words down, many writers become trapped in over-analysis. They constantly tweak the same paragraph instead of progressing through the manuscript. This reduces your productivity and can lead to burnout or you may abandon the project altogether.
To avoid this mistake, give yourself permission to write a messy first draft. Think of yourself as a sculptor. You need raw material before you can shape and refine your masterpiece. Separate your writing process from the revision and editing process. All great books started as rough drafts. Embrace imperfection and focus on progress over perfection.
Mistake #3: Underdeveloped Story Structure (for Fiction) or Lack of Clear Focus (for Nonfiction)
Many first-time writers dive into writing without an outline because they assume their story or message will naturally take shape as they go. While this approach works for some, most writers need structure to maintain clarity and direction. Without a roadmap, fiction writers can struggle with plot holes, inconsistent pacing, and weak resolutions. Nonfiction writers may find themselves meandering through unrelated topics, which leads to a book that lacks cohesion.
If you’re a fiction writer, learn the basic story structures, such as the three-act structure, the hero’s journey, or Save the Cat, to get a solid foundation for storytelling. You may not need to outline your entire novel, but it might be helpful to write down your major plot points and character arcs before writing. This can help prevent some narrative missteps.
If you’re a nonfiction writer, it’s important that you have a well-defined book thesis. Identify the central message of your book and make sure that every chapter will support that main idea. Then create an outline that breaks down key sections and subtopics. This will keep your writing focused. A well-structured book improves readability and enhances its impact for your readers.
Mistake #4: Weak or Unrealistic Characters (for Fiction)
Readers lose interest in books with poorly developed characters. New writers sometimes focus more on plot than character development, which results in flat or inconsistent characters. A character who lacks depth, believable motivations, or clear growth throughout the story can make even the most exciting plot feel lacking. Readers crave characters they can relate to, root for, or be intrigued by.
To create compelling characters, you’ll want to invest time in understanding their backstories, personality traits, and motivations. Think beyond surface-level, physical descriptions and delve into your characters’ fears, desires, and flaws. Then use dialogue and actions to reveal their personality rather than relying solely on exposition. Developing character profiles and writing short scenes from their perspective can help you bring them to life.
Mistake #5: Not Understanding Target Audience
Many first-time authors write based only on what they want to say and they don’t consider who will be reading their book. Passion for your topic is essential, of course, but ignoring your target audience can lead to a book that fails to connect with readers. Whether you’re writing fiction or nonfiction, it’s important to understand your audience’s preferences, expectations, and needs.
In order to reach your target audience, you’ll need to research your target audience by studying comparable books in your genre, engaging with potential readers through social media or forums, and analyzing feedback from beta readers. Think about what questions or problems your book addresses for nonfiction or what emotional experiences your story delivers for fiction. Writing with your audience in mind doesn’t mean you compromise your creativity, but it does ensure that your book resonates and meets readers where they are.
Mistake #6: Rushing the Editing Process
Excitement to publish quickly often leads writers to rush through (or skip) the editing process. However, editing is where the true magic happens. It’s where you refine your ideas, strengthen your prose, and ensure clarity. Without thorough editing, books suffer from grammar mistakes, structural issues, and inconsistencies that can make a book hard to read and unprofessional.
Self-editing is the first step and it shouldn’t be skipped, but it’s not enough. Take breaks between drafts, read your work aloud, and use editing tools to help catch simple errors. Next you’ll want to use beta readers. These readers offer valuable outside perspectives and highlight confusing sections or weak points of your story, so you can make additional revisions before you work with a professional editor. Finally, you’ll want to hire a professional editor to ensure your book is polished and ready for publication. The extra time you spend in editing will result in a stronger, more professional book.
Mistake #7: Ignoring Book Marketing Until It's Too Late
Many first-time authors believe that once their book is published, it will naturally find an audience without having to lift a finger. Unfortunately, without a solid marketing strategy, even the best books can go unnoticed.
To avoid this mistake, start marketing your book early—before it’s finished. Build an online presence using social media, a website, and an email newsletter. Engage with potential readers, share insights about your writing process, and establish yourself as an authority in your genre. Learn book marketing basics, such as launching strategies, Amazon optimization, and securing book reviews, to make a significant difference in your book’s success.
Mistake #8: Fear of Self-Promotion
Many writers struggle with self-promotion and they feel uncomfortable talking about their work or fear they’ll come across as pushy. Promotion isn’t about boasting, however, it’s about helping the right readers discover a book they’ll love or benefit from. Plus, you’re not really selling yourself, you’re selling your brand and your book. What made you passionate enough to write about your book is the same passion you can tap into to discuss your book’s topic with others.
I also want you to shift your mindset from selling to sharing. You don’t need to use a hard-sell pitch to sell your book. Instead, incorporate storytelling into your marketing. Share behind-the-scenes insights, share why you’re passionate about the topic or message of your book, what inspired you to write your book, who you dedicated your book to and why, and authentically engage with your audience. When you believe in your book’s value, talking about it becomes easier.
Mistake #9: Choosing the Wrong Publishing Path Without Research
Many first-time authors rush into publishing decisions without fully understanding the pros and cons of different paths. With options like self-publishing, traditional publishing, or hybrid models, each path has its own expectations, costs, and benefits.
Before you decide which path to take, research each route thoroughly. Consider factors like creative control, marketing responsibilities, royalty rates, and distribution options. Choosing the right publishing path ensures a smoother experience and aligns with your vision as an author.
Final Thoughts
Writing a book is a rewarding journey, but avoiding these common mistakes will help make the process smoother and more successful. If you stay consistent, embrace imperfect first drafts, structure your book well, and plan ahead for editing and marketing, you can set yourself up for a better self-publishing experience. Keep learning, keep writing, and most importantly—enjoy the process!
You are reading Xulon Press Substack, a weekly newsletter about writing, self-publishing, author branding, and creative living from Content Manager, Erika Bennett. You can also find us on Pinterest, Instagram, the Xulon Press blog, and our website.